Saturday, December 31, 2011

Bishops close adoption services over new rule on gay parents

Illinois bishops have jettisoned their adoption services rather than comply with non-discrimination laws.

ROMAN CATHOLIC bishops in Illinois have closed most of their church’s adoption and foster care services rather than comply with a new requirement that says they must consider same-sex couples as potential parents if they want to receive state money.

The charities have served for more than 40 years as a major link in the state’s social service network for poor and neglected children. 

Catholic Charities is a network whose aim is “to provide service to people in need, to advocate for justice in social structures, and to call the entire church and other people of good will to do the same”. 

The network is the second-largest social service provider in the United States, surpassed only by the federal government.

The Illinois bishops have followed colleagues in Washington DC and in Massachusetts who also jettisoned their adoption services rather than comply with non-discrimination laws.

For America’s Catholic bishops, the Illinois requirement is a prime example of what they see as an escalating campaign by the government to trample on their religious freedom while expanding the rights of gay people. 

The idea that religious Americans are the victims of government-backed persecution is now a frequent theme not just for Catholic bishops, but also for Republican presidential candidates and conservative evangelicals.

“In the name of tolerance, we’re not being tolerated,” said Bishop Thomas Paprocki of the diocese of Springfield, Illinios, a civil and canon lawyer who helped drive the church’s losing battle to retain its state contracts for foster care and adoption services.

The Illinois experience indicates that the bishops face formidable opponents who also claim to have justice and the constitution on their side. They include not only gay rights advocates, but also many religious believers and churches that support gay equality (some Catholic legislators among them). 

They frame the issue as a matter of civil rights, saying that Catholic Charities was using taxpayer money to discriminate against same-sex couples.

Tim Kee, a teacher in Marion, Illinois, who was turned away by Catholic Charities three years ago when he and his longtime partner, Rick Wade, tried to adopt a child, said: “We’re both Catholic, we love our church, but Catholic Charities closed the door to us. To add insult to injury, my tax dollars went to provide discrimination against me.”

The bishops are engaged in the religious liberty battle on several fronts. They have asked the Obama administration to lift a new requirement that Catholic and other religiously affiliated hospitals, universities and charity groups cover contraception in their employees’ health plans. A decision has been expected for weeks now.

At the same time, the bishops are protesting the recent denial of a federal contract to provide care for victims of sex-trafficking, saying the decision was anti-Catholic. 

An official with the department of health and human services recently told a hearing on Capitol Hill that the bishops’ programme was rejected because it did not provide the survivors of sex-trafficking, some of whom are rape victims, with referrals for abortions or contraceptives.

Critics of the church argue that no group has a constitutional right to a government contract, especially if it refuses to provide required services.

But Anthony Picarello, general counsel and associate general secretary of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, disagreed. “It’s true that the church doesn’t have a First Amendment right to have a government contract,” he said, “but it does have a First Amendment right not to be excluded from a contract based on its religious beliefs.”

The controversy in Illinois began when the state legislature voted in November 2010 to legalise civil unions for same-sex couples, which the state’s Catholic bishops lobbied against. 

The legislation was titled “The Illinois Religious Freedom Protection and Civil Unions Act”, and Paprocki said he was given the impression that it would not affect state contracts for Catholic Charities and other religious social services.

Catholic Charities serves more than 10 million poor adults and children of many faiths across the country. In Illinois, Catholic Charities in five of the six state dioceses had grown dependent on foster care contracts, receiving 60-92 per cent of their revenues from the state, according to affidavits by the charities’ directors.

When the contracts came up for renewal in June, the state attorney general, along with the legal staff in the governor’s office and the department of children and family services, decided the religious providers on state contracts would no longer be able to reject same-sex couples, said Kendall Marlowe, a spokesman for the department.

The Catholic providers offered to refer same-sex couples to other agencies (as they had been doing for unmarried couples), but that was not acceptable to the state, Marlowe said. 

“Separate but equal was not a sufficient solution on other civil rights issues in the past either,” he said.

Catholic Charities in the diocese of Rockford decided at that point to get out of the foster care business. 

But the bishops in Springfield, Peoria, Joliet and Belleville decided to fight, filing a lawsuit against the state.

Taking a different tack was the agency affiliated with the conservative Lutheran Church – Missouri Synod, which, like the Catholic Church, does not sanction same-sex relationships. 

Gene Svebakken, president and chief executive of the agency, Lutheran Child and Family Services of Illinois, visited all seven pastoral conferences in his state and explained that the best option was to compromise and continue caring for the children.

“We’ve been around 140 years, and if we didn’t follow the law we’d go out of business,” Svebakken said. “We believe it’s God-pleasing to serve these kids, and we know we do a good job.”

In August, Judge John Schmidt, a circuit judge in Sangamon County, ruled against Catholic Charities, saying, “No citizen has a recognised legal right to a contract with the government.”

He did not address the religious liberty claims, ruling only that the state did not violate the church’s property rights. 

Three of the dioceses filed an appeal, but in November filed a motion to dismiss their lawsuit. 

The dioceses of Peoria and Belleville are spinning off their state-financed social services, with the caseworkers, top executives and foster children all moving to new non-profits that will no longer be affiliated with either diocese.

Gary Huelsmann, executive director of Catholic Social Services of Southern Illinois, in the Belleville diocese, said the decision was excruciating for everyone.

“We have 600 children abused and neglected in an area where there are hardly any providers,” he said. “Us going out of business would have been detrimental to these children, and that’s a sin, too.”

The work will be carried on, but the Catholic Church’s seminal, historic connection with it has been severed, Marlowe noted.

“The child welfare system that Catholic Charities helped build,” he said, “is now strong enough to survive their departure.”

No comments: